Broadway Paper

One of my go-to places for cards and small novelty gifts. Staff are always super nice and helpful.

Great store! Stopped in because I was the area and it did not disappoint. There's so much arts and crafts items - from crocheting to scrapbooking and everything in between. Tons of card stock for invites, favors, and notes. Every kind of envelope shade and color you could ever hope for. Plus, there's a lot of cute stationary too! For those out of towners, this store also offers great souvenirs and keepsakes too.

You can count on them for unique, beautiful gifts. They carry Jellycat brand stuffed animals. Extraordinary! I bought long stick box matches, which are very hard to find, so a major score. Also, cute holiday tissue paper, a greeting card, thank you notes, a book, and a Jellycat stuffed animal!! Love this place.

Beautiful space with natural lighting and tons of unique and crafty items. Puzzles, journals, customer paper, posters, home decor, personal care and loads of Wisconsin-themed merch. Excited to visit again soon !

Fell in love with this place it’s jampacked with self wellness books galore, my witchy self was happy to see so many magical items for sale. It warmed my heart to see children astrology books 💫📚 The vintage stamp machine for a couple quarters 🪙 is also greatly appreciated 📮 The one I got said “Thank You Forever” in a regal gold font 💛